Kit and Curricular CompanionsInquiry CompanionClassroom ExperiencesTeachers' CommunityStandardsThe Weekly About KSNHome

 

Pennsbury School District, Edgewood Elementary School
March 2002

Diane DiMaggio and her 3rd grade students don't need an official lab filled with test tubes to explore chemistry. They can do it right in their small detached classroom at Edgewood Elementary School in the Pennsbury School District.

With help from STC's Chemical Tests kit, Diane has introduced her young chemists to basic concepts about matter and its changes. The class has been actively engaged in describing properties of objects and substances, conducting simple tests, and systematically recording observations as they work to solve the mystery of five unknown solids—common household substances identified only by colored sticker dots.

Considering the unknowns. Based on their early observations, teams of students have made predictions about what each of the unknowns might be. They have also experimented by combining each unknown solid with a liquid (water); observed what happened when the substances interacted; and poured their mixtures through filters into Petri dishes.

They discuss solutions and suspensions. Diane began the lesson by compiling the group's observations, asking whether or not each unknown dissolved, if the liquid was cloudy or clear, and if the mixture was a solution or a suspension, or both. Students were able to refer to their own direct experience as they used this scientific terminology.

All agreed that the red sample had dissolved in the water and that the clear result could be called a solution. The green unknown made the water cloudy and murky. It "stayed in blobs" so was recognized as a suspension. And as they continued to add small amounts of the yellow and blue to the water, mixtures reached a point where no more could dissolve, leaving the water clear but with some unknown still visible on the bottom of the cup.

One sample left many students feeling "iffy"—the mixture was cloudy and milky, but so watery some felt the unknown had "kind of dissolved." They will repeat the test the next day to come to a more satisfactory conclusion.

Looking closely at solids. The next step was for students to look closely at solids remaining on the filter paper and evaporation dishes used in their previous test. The Chemical Tests unit is materials intensive, but cardboard lab trays and colored stickers help to keep things organized. Organization also makes the distribution of materials and movement around the room go smoothly: Diane reminds students that each team member has a particular task—number ones get the "science bucket," twos clean up, and threes get the tray.

Students record observations. Following the basic direction "Whatever you see, write down, " students begin to record their observations. Diane also suggests drawing pictures as another way of representing results.

Students share their observations. As the groups go to work, students share and compare their observations: "I saw something glisten," "sticky crystals," and "It looks like broken pieces of plastic, or sugar stuck together."

Students use other senses to observe. Although Diane reminds students that that tasting is NOT a good idea, using other senses can add to visual observations: "This smells like baking soda." Another unknown was described as having a sweet scent, or no scent at all.

Diane makes sure everyone can participate. Time is always a concern when doing science investigations, but Diane has found a way to coordinate with the special education schedule and have all students participate. Rather than having every team do tests on all five unknowns, each group works on three. All samples are examined, and the class as a whole has data to solve the mystery.

Looking forward to the following day, Diane explained that the class would again pool their observations to discover which mixtures could be separated by filtration and which by evaporation. As they conduct further tests during the rest of the unit, students will continue to practice their investigation skills and apply their knowledge to solve new mysteries.

Many thanks to Diane and students for inviting us into their laboratory!

Back to Classroom Experiences.


The Franklin Institute gratefully acknowledges the generous support of the National Science Foundation and Unisys Corporation.

The
Franklin Institute National Science Foundation Unisys

ENC Logo
The Franklin Institute is the Demonstration Site for the Eisenhower Mid-Atlantic Consortium, providing science and math resources for teachers.

This material is based upon work supported by the National Science Foundation under Grant No. 9819641.
Any opinions, findings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation.

webteam@keystone.fi.edu

© 2003. All rights reserved.